Campania Coal-Fired Pizza

The service was terrible. The waiter never came to our table after we got our food. One of the dinners was wrong and we had to get it fixed. Our waiter was nowhere to be found. No one brought us condiments. No offer on drink refills. We had to keep grabbing other people like the manager at the hostess station to help us. We still left a 20% tip but I doubt we’ll ever go back. At their prices I was hoping for a better experience. The place was about 25% full I can only imagine how much worse the service is when it’s busy. Update: we went back last night and the server we had was let go. The manager remembered us and adjusted our bill. Anthony our server was polite and professional and we had an amazing dinner to celebrate our wedding anniversary. Thank you for making it right!

- Noelle Brunetti -

This is a great place for small or big party gathering. I feel like the portion is not very big. There are a few dishes that I really like. The pizza we ordered is amazing. It’s thin crust which is similar to Italian style. The steak is very good too. We had medium rare, and the texture of the meat wasn’t too hard to chew. It was soft and juicy. We had 9 people so at the end we ordered a lot of desserts. I personally really like the lava cake and the cheesecake tastes good as well! I would recommend you to stop by and try this restaurant if you are around Staten Island. The atmosphere is chill. It’s just a little hard for big party to chat when there are a lot of people because it is a little loud. Also, I personally think it’s a little too dark inside especially we sat down all the way inside.

- Jasmine Lam -

I had a good experience at Campania Coal-Fired Pizza. I tried the grilled calamari, which was a bit on the chewy side, but the fried artichoke hearts were very good and I would definitely recommend them. The food overall is pretty good, though not perfect. What really stands out is the service - the staff and bartenders are very friendly and attentive. The atmosphere is also nice. While there's room for improvement with some dishes, it's worth visiting for the quality service and decent food.

- Phil Gill -

Rooftop and outdoor seating available this pizza restaurant is a place one can go to celebrate any occasion. Menu is diverse and a great bar there isn’t much missing from this establishment. Decor is modern with a spin on class, no wonder I witness a lot of tables filled with people celebrating birthdays. If you can’t pick one style of pizza go for making the pie 1/2 and 1/2. Not in the mood for pizza? There are dinner plate selections that I will try the next time I’m around. Leave room for dessert, lots of selections to chose from as well.

- Del Rodriguez -

It's a bit loud and always busy and that's part of the draw. You feel like you're out at the neighborhood place and the food has been consistently good though I sometimes struggle to find something I want to order and settle for the pizza (love the buffalo chicken) and a mixed pot to share with the table.

- Valerie Tagliavia -

If it wasn’t for all the younger staff just all hanging out in the corner or one of the young servers was just walking around watching the game on tv and wouldn’t stop whistling then 5 stars. The food is great. Everything was prepared the way we like. Everything had flavor. The potions are great.

- Rene Palaguachi -

Campania in Staten Island isn't your average pizzeria; it's a culinary haven. Their pizza is a masterpiece of flavor and texture, while their non-traditional offerings like hamburgers and steaks are equally impressive. The cozy atmosphere and attentive staff make dining here a delight. If you're in search of exceptional food and a welcoming ambiance, Campania is the place to be.

- Thomas P Smith NY REAL ESTATE -

This a place is for comfort food! The food is always fantastic and services is always great! I’m a frequent customer anytime I’m around I definitely have to stop in with the family! Definitely a Must try!

- Ceaz G -